Best Nut Butters for Ninja Creami
This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The Contenders
We tested five nut butters in the same base recipe to compare flavor, texture, and mix-ability.
Results
1. Creamy Peanut Butter (Winner)
Classic flavor, blends smoothly, available everywhere. Natural or regular both work — natural has more peanut flavor.
Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter{rel="sponsored nofollow"}
2. Almond Butter
Milder, nuttier flavor than peanut butter. Blends smoothly. Great for pairing with chocolate.
Justin's Classic Almond Butter{rel="sponsored nofollow"}
3. Cashew Butter
Creamy and mild with a subtle sweetness. Blends the smoothest of all nut butters.
4. Biscoff Cookie Butter
Technically not a nut butter, but it's incredible in the Creami. Warm, spiced, caramelized flavor.
Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter{rel="sponsored nofollow"}
5. Hazelnut Spread (Nutella)
Chocolate-hazelnut is a crowd favorite. Very sweet — reduce sugar in the recipe.
Tips for All Nut Butters
- Warm for 10-15 seconds in microwave before mixing — it blends easier
- For swirls: Warm until pourable, drizzle into base, drag a knife through
- For mix-ins: Freeze small dollops, then fold in with Mix-In function
- Natural nut butters have more authentic flavor but separate more