Best Greek Yogurts for Frozen Yogurt

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

The Test

Plain yogurt + honey + vanilla, six different brands. Judged on creaminess, tanginess, and overall frozen yogurt quality.

The Results

1. Fage Total (Full-Fat)

Thick, creamy, and tangy. The highest fat content (10%) produces the creamiest frozen yogurt. Our top pick.

Fage Total Greek Yogurt{rel="sponsored nofollow"}

2. Chobani Whole Milk

Widely available, creamy, and slightly less tangy than Fage. Great results.

3. Stonyfield Organic Whole Milk

Organic option with good fat content. Mild flavor.

4. Siggi's Whole Milk

Icelandic-style (skyr). Very thick, less tangy. Produces dense frozen yogurt.

5. 2% Greek Yogurt (Any brand)

Acceptable but noticeably icier. Add 1 tablespoon cream cheese to compensate.

6. Non-Fat Greek Yogurt

Not recommended. Too icy without added stabilizers.

Key Findings

• Full-fat (5-10% MF) is essential for creamy frozen yogurt
• Tanginess varies — Fage is tangier, Chobani is milder
• Thickness matters — Thicker yogurts produce denser, better frozen yogurt
• Flavored yogurt works — Strawberry, vanilla, honey varieties save a step